An image of Edgar Allan Poe (1809–1849) as a man of gloom and mystery continues to hold great popular appeal. Long recognized as one of the greats of American literature, he elicited either highly commendatory or absolutely hostile reactions from many who knew him, from others who claimed to comprehend him as person or as writer, and from still others who circulated as fact opinions intuited from his writings. Whether promoting him as angel or demon, “a man of great and original genius” or “extraordinarily wicked,” the viewpoints in this dramatic collection of primary materials provide vigorous testimony to support the contradictory images of the man and the writer that have prevailed for a century and a half.
Noted Poe scholar Benjamin Fisher includes a comprehensive introduction and a detailed chronology of Poe’s sadly short life; each entry is introduced by a short headnote that places the selection in historical and cultural context, and explanatory notes provide information about people and places. From John Allan’s letter to Secretary of War John Eaton about Poe’s West Point life to John Frankenstein’s hostile verse casting him as an alcoholic, from Rufus Griswold’s first and second posthumous vilifications to James Russell Lowell’s more sensible outline of his life and career, from scornful to commendable reviews to scathing attacks on his morals to recognition of his comic achievements, Fisher has gathered a lively array of materials that read like the most far-fetched of gothic tales.
Poe himself was creative when he supplied information about his life and literary career to others, and the speculative content of many of the portrayals presented in this collection read as if their authors had set out to be equally creative. The sixty-nine recollections gathered in Poe in His Own Time form a dramatic, real-time biographical narrative designed to provide a multitude of perspectives on the famous author, sometimes in conflict with each other and sometimes in agreement but always arresting.
“Poe in His Own Time is a must for all who wish to trace Poe’s life without the embroidery of biography. Fisher’s judiciously selected excerpts provide the reader with a collection that would have taken years to access otherwise. Fisher’s general introduction and prefaces to the reminiscences attest to his forty years as a Poe scholar whose commitment to evidentiary research can be trusted, embraced, and enjoyed.”—Barbara Cantalupo, editor, Edgar Allan Poe Review
“Like its predecessors in this outstanding series, Poe in His Own Time succeeds as both a rich sourcebook for scholars and a fascinating read for nonspecialists. Selected, arranged, and annotated with exemplary skill by its editor, Benjamin Fisher, this chronological collection of primary materials evokes its subject with a wonderful immediacy, transporting us back into the very thick of Poe’s turbulent life and times.”—Harold Schechter, author, Nevermore
“It is very useful to have such a striking array of verbal portraits and snapshots of Poe in one handy volume. One would have to consult letters, biographies, and dozens of other sources in order to obtain such a concise yet moving picture of Poe. This collection reminds us why Poe cut a controversial figure in his day. Poe’s friends and enemies alike can be heard in their own embattled voices.”—Stephen Rachman, Michigan State University, and president, Poe Studies
Association
Introduction xi
Chronology xxvii
John Allan, [Letter about Poe’s West Point Matriculation] (1829) 1
Allan B. Magruder, [Letter about Poe at West Point] (1884) 2
John P. Kennedy, [Letter about Commencement of Poe’s Professional Literary Life] (1835) 3
Thomas W. White, [Letter about Poe’s Drinking and the Messenger] (1835) 4
John P. Kennedy, [Letter about Mixed Modes in Poe’s Early Tales] (1836) 6
Edgar A. Poe, [Epistolary Response with Comment on Humor] (1836) 7
James Kirke Paulding, [Harper’s Rejection of “Tales of the Folio Club”] (1836) 8
James Kirke Paulding, [Letter Advising Poe to Compose a Novel] (1836) 9
Lydia H. Sigourney, [Letter Justifying Poe’s Critical Practices] (1836) 10
Edgar A. Poe, [Letter Seeking Political Appointment] (1841) 11
Frederick W. Thomas, [Letter Encouraging Poe’s Political Desires] (1841) 12
Edgar A. Poe, [Additional Comments on Political Aspirations] (1841) 13
Frederick W. Thomas, [Letter about Poe’s Political Qualifications] (1841) 14
[Anonymous], “Autographs” (1842) 15
Frederick W. Thomas, [Letter about Poe’s Possible Custom House Appointment] (1842) 16
Edgar A. Poe, [Letter about Reasons for Leaving Graham’s] (1842) 18
Rufus W. Griswold, From The Poets and Poetry of America (1842) 20
[Edgar A. Poe and Henry B. Hirst], From “Poets and Poetry of Philadelphia . . .” (1843) 23
George Lippard, “Mr. Poe’s Lecture” (1843) 41
Academicus, “For the Delaware State Journal” (1844) 43
George Lippard, “Lecture by Mr. Poe” (1844) 46
Edgar A. Poe, [Letter Detailing Life in New York City] (1844) 47
Lawrence Labree, [Early Criticism of Poe’s Works] (1845) 49
Cornelia Wells Walter, From “A Failure” (1845) 52
P., From “Edgar A. Poe” in Boston Evening Transcript (1845) 54
[Anonymous], “Quizzing the Bostonians” (1845) 56
[Anonymous], “Mr. Poe’s Poem” (1845) 57
M. B. Fields, From Memories of Many Men and of Some Women (1875) 59
[Anonymous], From “Hints to Authors” (1848) 60
[Evert A. Duyckinck], [Untitled Headnote to Reprint of “Ulalume”] (1849) 66
[Anonymous], From “Mr. Poe’s Lecture” (1849) 67
John M. Daniel, From “Edgar A. Poe” in Semi-Weekly
Examiner (1849) 68
Joseph P. Wilson, [Note Requesting Assistance for Poe] (1849) 70
John J. Moran, [Letter from Poe’s Attending Physician] (1849) 71
“Ludwig” [Rufus Wilmot Griswold], “Death of Edgar Allan Poe” in New York Daily Tribune (1849) 73
[C. F. Briggs], From “Topics of the Month” (1849) 81
Maria Clemm, “To the Reader” (1850) 84
James Russell Lowell, “Edgar A. Poe” (1850) 86
Nathaniel P. Willis, “Death of Edgar A. Poe” (1850) 94
Rufus Wilmot Griswold, “Memoir of the Author” (1850) 100
Henry B. Hirst, “Edgar Allan Poe” in McMakin’s Model American Courier (1849) 154
John M. Daniel, From “Edgar Allan Poe” in Southern Literary Messenger (1850) 159
John R. Thompson, “The Late Edgar A. Poe” in Southern Literary Messenger (1849) 161
John R. Thompson, From “Editor’s Table” (1850) 167
[John R. Thompson], Editorial Note to “Poe on Headley and Channing” (1850) 168
Nathaniel P. Willis, “Estimates of Edgar A. Poe” in Home Journal (1850) 169
Anonymous, From Athenaeum (1852) 173
“Apollodorus” [George Gilfillan], “Authors and Books. Edgar Poe.” (1854) 174
Rufus Wilmot Griswold, “Preface” to Works of the Late Edgar A. Poe (1856) 187
William Moy Thomas, “Edgar Allan Poe: A Letter to the Editor of The Train” (1857) 188
Bryan W. Proctor, From “Edgar Allan Poe” in Edinburgh Review (1858) 195
[Anonymous], “Editorial Etchings” (1858) 208
[Anonymous], From “Nathaniel Hawthorne” (1860) 209
Mary Gove Nichols, “Reminiscences of Edgar Poe” (1863) 210
John Frankenstein, From American Art (1864) 217
Elizabeth Oakes Smith, “Autobiographic Notes. Edgar Allan Poe.” (1867) 219
Joseph E. Snodgrass, “The Facts of Poe’s Death and Burial” (1867) 236
Margaret E. Wilmer, “Another View of Edgar A. Poe” (1867) 245
William Gowans, From Edgar Allan Poe (1891) 249
John Henry Ingram, “Edgar Poe” in Temple Bar (1874) 251
Francis Gerry Fairfield, “A Mad Man of Letters” (1875) 266
F. R. M., From “The Poet Not an Epileptic” (1875) 285
Sarah Helen Whitman, From “Poe, Critic, and Hobby. A Reply to Mr. Fairfield . . .” (1875) 286
[Anonymous], From [Editorial Notice of Reply to Fairfield] (1875) 290
Francis Gerry Fairfield, From “Edgar Allan Poe. A Letter . . .” (1875) 291
Charles Frederick Briggs, From “The Personality of Poe” (1877) 294
Bibliography 301
Index 305
Patrick F. Quinn Award for best book on Poe published in 2010
